1. Vocabulary Test Results
Table 4 summarizes the descriptive statistics for the value-laden vocabulary pre- and post-tests administered to both groups, including group means, standard deviations, and gain scores. The experimental group scored higher on the pre-test (
M = 37) than the control group (
M = 32), with a five-point difference. On the post-test, the experimental group (
M = 79) also outperformed the control group (
M = 57). Both groups improved, but the experimental group showed a larger gain (42 points) compared to the control group (25 points).
Item-level analysis indicated that the experimental group outperformed the control group across recognition, recall, and production items. Some responses received zero scores when they were grammatically correct but failed to meet task requirements (e.g., “You are wrong”). In contrast, responses conveying the intended meaning, despite minor errors, received full credit (e.g., “It is wrong because she didn’t tell truth” [sic]).
2. Qualitative Findings by Instructional Progression
This section presents a qualitative analysis of students’ critical literacy responses, focusing on initial response patterns, shifts in perspective-taking, use of evaluative vocabulary, and depth of justification. Findings are organized by the three texts and indicate general tendencies toward increased interpretive depth and critical engagement, despite some variability across sessions.
1) Prince Cinders
At the beginning of the intervention, several students showed hesitation in expressing their ideas, suggesting limited experience with discussion-based activities. In the initial brainstorming task using Prince Cinders, responses focused on surface features (e.g., “He is ugly,” “A pretty princess is better”).
Following the reading and discussion activities, students identified the theme of the story in a summary worksheet, demonstrating a shift from simple retelling to value-based interpretation. As shown in
Figure 1, students expressed messages such as “Looks aren’t everything” (EG3) and “Inner kindness is more important than appearance” (EG2).
In contrast, the control group’s theme interpretations tended to be superficial or not clearly connected to the central message (e.g., “The story was funny,” “Let’s be nice to our younger brother”). Although both groups received guiding questions and feedback, the focus differed. In the experimental group, additional questioning promoted deeper reflection, leading students to recognize how appearance-centered values in the original fairy tale were challenged and transformed in the parody. In the third lesson, students compared the original story with its parody and considered the author’s intention, as illustrated in
Figure 2.
In the comparison task, EG1 initially described characters as “always right” or “always wrong,” reflecting a fixed and polarized interpretation. Through drafting and revision, students elaborated on their ideas and provided more detailed justification. Follow-up questions (e.g., “Why did the author change the story?”) prompted deeper reflection on the author’s intention. For example, EG2 stated the change was “to make it more fun,” while EG4 wrote, “Some people want boy main character” [sic], indicating emerging awareness of gender differences.
In a later response, EG4 further explained that the author changed the gender to challenge stereotypes, promote equality, and add humor through role reversal. The use of more advanced vocabulary (e.g., “gender,” “equality,” “role reversal,” and “normal”) suggests a shift from surface-level explanations to more critical interpretations.
2) The True Story of the 3 Little Pigs!
In the lesson on
The True Story of the 3 Little Pigs, students identified the theme using the same format, with responses showing varying levels of interpretive depth, as shown in
Figure 3.
EG4 wrote “Let’s study hard,” linking this interpretation to the third pig’s decision to build a brick house, which requires effort and ensures safety. While this reflects engagement with the original storyline, it also indicates reliance on a conventional moral framework rather than recognition of the parody’s shifted perspective. Through teacherguided questioning, EG4 initially explained the response based on the third pig’s intelligence but, after being encouraged to reconsider the story from another perspective, shifted toward recognizing the wolf’s perspective. Ultimately, the student stated, “We should listen to everyone,” indicating a shift toward considering multiple perspectives, including the wolf’s version of the story.
Following this interaction, EG4 revised the initial response (“Let’s study hard”) to reflect this perspective, demonstrating emerging awareness of multiple viewpoints. However, some students continued to produce generalized moral interpretations (e.g., “Don’t speak if you don’t know”), which were only partially connected to the parody’s central message. In contrast, responses such as “The wolf is innocent” and “There are two sides to every story” reflected clearer recognition of multiple perspectives and the text’s reframing.
Overall, students showed varying levels of interpretation, but prompts and interaction supported a shift toward deeper perspective-taking, which was less evident in the control group. Following the task, a fact-opinion worksheet showed that some students could distinguish evaluative expressions (e.g., “kind,” “rude,” and “selfish”) from factual statements, as shown in
Figure 4.
In contrast, EG4 classified “The wolf is male” as an opinion, while EG1 treated “The wolf is bad” as a fact, indicating confusion between fact and evaluation. As distinguishing between fact and opinion was important for subsequent activities, selected responses were reviewed collectively, allowing students to revise their classifications.
Building on this, students engaged in a fake news-making activity, which encouraged critical reflection on how images and perspectives shape interpretation. Through this process, students demonstrated more developed responses than in earlier tasks.
For example, EG1 interpreted the wolf’s actions as part of the law of nature, while EG3 suggested that the third pig had “intentionally excluded” [sic] the first and second pigs, allowing them to be harmed by the wolf. EG4 argued that the wolf’s explanation was an excuse rather than a valid reason. These responses, as shown in
Figure 5, reflect more critical, perspective-based interpretations, with students also using self-generated images to support their messages. Through this process, students learned that images can serve as effective multimodal tools for communicating ideas and reinforcing perspectives.
Reasoning depth varied, ranging from basic justification to more advanced critical interpretation. Overall, students showed gradual improvement in explaining their ideas. While the control group also engaged in writing tasks, these focused on conventional activities (e.g., describing memorable scenes), whereas the experimental group reconstructed the story with attention to intention and audience.
3) Trust Me, Jack’s Beanstalk Stinks!: The Story of Jack and the Beanstalk as Told by the Giant
According to field notes, students participated more actively and expressed their opinions more freely than in previous sessions. However, some students occasionally mixed Korean and English due to gaps in their English proficiency, and certain words (e.g., guilt and bold) were not clearly understood and required clarification.
In the summary task, most students expressed generalized themes (e.g., “You should not steal,” “Greed is not good”), while EG4’s response initially remained event-based, as reflected in the statement “Don’t hide in another person’s house,” which refers to the scene in which Jack secretly enters the Giant’s house and waits to steal his belongings. During follow-up questioning, the student showed hesitation (e.g., “I don’t know”) and produced simplified moral judgments (e.g., “rich is bad” [sic]; “because of thief” [sic]). Rather than providing direct correction, the teacher used guiding questions to prompt reconsideration. Through this process, EG4 gradually moved from a fixed, simplified interpretation toward recognizing differing perspectives between Jack and the Giant, eventually revising the response to “Jack and the Giant can have different ideas.”
In contrast, control group responses focused on general moral statements, showing superficial engagement with underlying perspectives. This highlights the role of critical literacy-based questioning in fostering deeper interpretation. Students further extended their ideas through a Padlet activity, as illustrated in
Figure 6, which allowed them to view and share peers’ responses and to attach their own drawings or images to support their ideas.
Students further explored perspective transformation through the Padlet activity, expressing more elaborated ideas than in earlier tasks. For example, EG1 and EG4 reconsidered character roles and alternative perspectives. This shift was supported by the activity’s informal format and use of images. Compared to direct presentations, sharing ideas through Padlet appeared to reduce learners’ anxiety and encourage more diverse and flexible expressions of ideas and perspectives. Building on this, students engaged in a mock trial, stating their stance and reasons before organizing arguments for both sides using a T-chart, as shown in
Figure 7.
Students compared Jack’s and the Giant’s perspectives and justified their reasoning, with EG3 emphasizing the Giant’s ownership (“the gold hen were his property” [sic]) and EG1 highlighting the harm caused by the Giant. The use of vocabulary such as “property,” “permission,” and “hurt” indicates a shift toward more balanced, evidencebased interpretation.
In the mock trial, students took positions and supported them with textual evidence, identifying relevant scenes and defending their viewpoints while engaging with alternative perspectives. Working in pairs, they also anticipated opposing arguments.
Group 1: Jack is very poor. Jack's mom is poor, too.
Group 2: Even if you are poor, you should not steal.
Group 1: But the Giant eat [sic] people because the Giant is hungry, kill people... so it is murder.
Group 2: But the Giant's diet is humans, so he cannot help it. (Conversation 1, Mock Trial Interaction (Jack vs. the Giant))
This interaction illustrates students’ engagement in perspective-taking and moral reasoning. Group 1 emphasized economic hardship and moral judgment (e.g., “Jack is very poor,” “murder”), while Group 2 justified the Giant’s actions from biological or contextual perspectives (e.g., “the Giant’s diet is humans,” “he cannot help it”).
Students used evaluative vocabulary and connectors (e.g., “because”) to justify their ideas, demonstrating expanded language use. They also showed positive engagement, expressing enjoyment in identifying evidence and a willingness to participate in similar activities, such as mock trials.
3. Summary of Changes in Student Responses
The data presented in
Table 5 were drawn from the lesson materials used across all instructional stages (Who, Where, What Happens? Worksheet). As the Theme (Message/Lesson) section of the worksheet reflects students’ interpretation of the text and their understanding of the author’s intention, this section was selected and reorganized to examine changes in students’ responses over time. Students’ written responses showed variation in interpretive depth across sessions rather than a consistent progression, although some responses indicated emerging attempts at more interpretive and perspective-based understanding. The responses are presented as originally written to preserve authenticity.
For instance, EG1 initially wrote, “Be kind to others,” in response to Prince Cinders, expressing a simple moral message. In a later response to Trust Me, Jack’s Beanstalk Stinks!, the student wrote, “Put yourself in someone’s shoes,” suggesting an emerging awareness of perspective-taking and alternative viewpoints. Similar tendencies were observed among other students, although the development was not always linear, and students demonstrated varying levels of interpretive understanding across the different texts.
Finally, to investigate changes in student vocabulary use across the instructional sequence, the evaluative and value-laden words used by individual students in their worksheet responses were analyzed. Vocabulary use was categorized into positive, negative, character-describing, emotional, and critical/evaluative types. The results are summarized in
Table 6.
In the early stages, students mainly relied on a limited set of evaluative words (e.g., “right,” “wrong,” and “different”) drawn from the provided vocabulary list. Over time, however, they began to incorporate a wider range of expressions to articulate their ideas more precisely. Notably, some of the later vocabulary items (e.g., “perspective” and “permission”) were not included in the provided list, suggesting that students actively extended their vocabulary through independent exploration. Overall, the results indicate a shift from general descriptive terms (e.g., “brave,” “selfish,” and “rude”) to more critical and evaluative vocabulary in later stages.
After the instructional sessions, students reported that they found evaluative vocabulary challenging but attempted to use it in context (e.g., “gender discrimination” and “unfair”). However, few responses included detailed justification, suggesting that while vocabulary use improved, the ability to provide clear reasoning was still developing. Students also reported high engagement, particularly in the fake news and mock trial activities, expressing enjoyment in using images, writing texts, and exploring alternative perspectives. Overall, these responses indicate positive affective engagement, although based on limited self-reported data.